I agree 100%. This is the first Insomnium album I have listened to from beginning to end.....and I like it very much. I like the sense of despondency you get listening to the album. I also plucked out "Pale Morning Star" as an epic masterpiece from Heart Like a Grave. The entire song isn't really that melancholy, IMHO. It does build to some intense speed and power, however, the lyrics are drenched in immense sadness of a lost loved one...........
I feel the whole album is a grand performance and well written. What other albums should I listen to? I know I said earlier I was going to listen to Above the Weeping World but never got around to it.
edit: Another album that landed in my inbox, In Mourning - Garden of Storms which was also released October 4th. Ever hear of them? Seems very similar to Insomnium on a skip through listen.....
I'd definitely recommend starting with
Shadows of the Dying Sun if you liked
Heart Like A Grave that much. It's got a similar "hope in despair" sound to it. Pretty much everything they did before
Shadows of the Dying Sun is just "despair." LOL.
Winter's Gate is a pretty good concept album. It's one 40 minute song split up into 7 tracks. There's a decent amount of variety in it.
If you're up for just despair, then you can honestly take your pick from the rest of the bunch.
One For Sorrow was the first album that hinted at a more positive direction for the band lyrically. Most folks would likely recommend
Above The Weeping World. It's a pretty good album, but just know that the vocals are super intense.
Across the Dark is probably my favorite of their older albums (and also has similarly intense vocals), but they're all good.
I actually own a couple of older In Mourning albums, but I've barely touched them. I know they're a melodic death metal band, but I don't even remember what they sound like.